[Bug/Sound] Final Fantasy X : Voice problems

[squarealex]

Hello dear menbre, moderator, administrator and especially developers of PCSX2.

I have a minor problem with FFX, not very common on forums apparently.
These are the voices of peronnages during the dialogue stage, their voices are sometimes bad, as this frequency Sample Rate is low. Then after that comes in good quality. And sometimes it again.

I Selected part or you can hear this bug.
A square in the upper right of the video as a caption.
Red = bad
Green = Good / Normal

Warning this video contains Spoiler



My version of Final Fantasy X is a French release.
My Version of PCSX2 is PCSX2 1.1.0.5722 (svn)

[jesalvein]

In order to help you further with your problem, please make sure the following are all provided.

• Your hardware specs - CPU, Graphics Card, Memory, Operating System.
  
• The version of PCSX2 you are using.
  
• Any non default settings you are using.
  
• What games you are trying to play and if you are playing them from ISO or DVD.
  

Thank You.

[xenoriddley]

Might be because I'm partially deaf in my right ear, but it sounds just fine to me.

[tsunami2311]

sound fine to me too, but hey what do we know

[squarealex]

Yes.

My CPU : Intel i7 [email protected]
My GPU : nVidia GTX 770@2GB
RAM : 8 Go DDR3
OS : Windows 7x64

PCSX2 Version : PCSX2 1.1.0.5722 (svn)

emuLog.txt

PCSX2 1.1.0.r5722 - compiled on Aug 25 2013
Savestate version: 0x9a0a0000

Host Machine Init:
Operating System = Microsoft Windows 7 Service Pack 1 (build 7601), 64-bit
Physical RAM = 8138 MB
CPU name = Intel® Core™ i7-3770K CPU @ 3.50GHz
Vendor/Model = GenuineIntel (stepping 09)
CPU speed = 3.509 ghz (8 logical threads)
x86PType = Standard OEM
x86Flags = bfebfbff 7f9ae3bf
x86EFlags = 28100000

x86 Features Detected:
MMX.. SSE.. SSE2.. SSE3.. SSSE3.. SSE4.1.. SSE4.2.. AVX

Reserving memory for recompilers...

Loading plugins...
Binding GS: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\GSdx32-AVX-r5724.dll
Windows 6.1.7601 (Service Pack 1 1.0)
Binding PAD: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\lilypad-r5350.dll
Binding SPU2: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\SPU2-X-r5695.dll
Binding CDVD: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\cdvdGigaherz.dll
Binding USB: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\USBnull.dll
Binding FW: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\FWnull.dll
Binding DEV9: D:\Stockage\Emulateur\PlayStation 2\PCSX2 - 1.0.0\plugins\DEV9null-r5684.dll
Plugins loaded successfully.

(GameDB) 9645 games on record (loaded in 135ms)
(GameDB) Unloading...

Plugin Sound : SPU2-X r5695 2.0

Interpolation : 4 / LikePS2
Use the de-alias filter

Output Setting :
XAudio 2
Volume : 100%
Latency : 142ms (avg)
Synch Mode : Time Stretch
Audio Expansion : Stéréo

Ther Other setting for SPU2-X is disabled

SpeedHack is disabled

GSdx 5724 - AVX
DirectX 11 Hardware Mode
3x Native
Texture filtering
8-Bits textures

Game : Final Fantasy X - PAL - French Version SCES_504.91

EDIT :
I'll try to make a comparison between the PS2 version and the version of emulator

[rmcin329]

sounds 100% normal to me.

[masterotaku]

I can clearly notice the difference. I don't know if that's normal or not in the english dub, but those changes seem very random. It isn't like "high polygon models = good sound, low polygon models = bad sound".

[jesalvein]

looks like a bad surround sound management. as if some voices werent coming out from the right speaker.
@OP : do you have the same problem if you set SPU2-x config to surround 5.1 or quadraphonic ?

[nintendo85]

I notice it as well, my ears are very sensitive, there are slight inconsistencies, not sure what's causes it.